Lodewijk Muns


home

William Hogarth (engr. Ravenet), frontispice for Laurence Sterne’s Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy, 1760

C. P. E.Bach, Haydn, and the art of mixed feelings: 
‘Empfindsamkeit’ and ‘wit’ in the keyboard works

The concept of ‘Empfindsamkeit’ in music has been insufficiently defined. An attempt to establish the scope of the musical Empfindsamkeit has to take into account the moral-emotional aspects of the international movement of ‘sensibility’. Moses Mendelssohn’s concept of ‘vermischte Empfindungen’, which he developed around the central empfindsam concept of ‘pity’, articulates an awareness of greater complexity of emotional states in aesthetic context. Such complexity is expressed in some of the keyboard works of Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach and of Joseph Haydn.

The works of Laurence Sterne, often associated with Haydn, are paradigmatic for the emotional-aesthetic complexity of the Empfindsamkeit.

text (pdf)
       
Music & Drama
Een en ’n ander
Who’s I?
Pedrillo Botón
Philosophy
Magic, signs, and making sense
God and the calculus of belief
Musicology
C.P.E. Bach, Haydn, ...
Why I am not a Schenkerian
Schumann's First Symphony
contact

Alhorend oor (after Chodowiecki & Gray's Anatomy; (c) Lodewijk Muns)

Why I am not a Schenkerian

In the world of music theory, 'Schenkerism' causes a major divide.  For some the ideas of Heinrich Schenker (1868-1935) constitute the most profound and comprehensive theory of tonal music; others see only a flagrant negation of common sense and musical understanding. In between the orthodox and the unbelievers stand the liberals and pragmatists. The pragmatist attitude implies that a fundamental debate is futile. To me it seems a necessity: if music theory is cultivated on relativist islands, it is doomed to irrelevance.

Well-founded ‘refutations’ of Schenkerism are scarce. The disagreement goes far beyond technicalities: it involves principles of an aesthetic, epistemological and ontological nature. First of all it is necessary to discover these basic presuppositions which underly analytical judgments on either side.

text (pdf)

© Lodewijk Muns 2011